---
title: "Terms for Contributed Works — Library of Provenance"
description: "What a work in the Library of Provenance tells you: the contributor attestation, how contributors are verified, the review criteria, what is public and private, and what the signature means."
url: https://instituteofprovenance.org/library/terms
source: Institute of Provenance
---
[Library](/library)/Terms for Contributed Works

# Terms for Contributed Works

What a work in the Library of Provenance tells you, who stands behind it, and what the Institute does and does not vouch for. These terms apply to every work the Institute did not write itself.

## At a glance

### Contributors are responsible for their works

Each contributor attests that the named authors wrote the work and that it may be published, and accepts responsibility for its content.

### Every contributor is verified

The Institute confirms who each contributor is before anything is published, and records how in the work’s signed record.

### We check the criteria, not the argument

Works are accepted against short, published criteria. The Institute does not judge whether a work is right, and it publishes opposing views.

### Inclusion is not endorsement

The Institute signs the record so anyone can check that the work and its attribution haven’t changed. A signature proves integrity, not truth.

## The contributor’s attestation

Before a work is published, its contributor approves the work as formatted for the Library and makes this attestation. The work’s signed record names the version they made.

Attestation iop-library-v1

> The contributor attests that the named authors wrote this work, that the contributor is one of them or is authorized by them to submit it, and that the rights to publish it are held as stated. The contributor accepts responsibility for the content of the work, including its accuracy and any statements it makes about people or organizations. The Institute of Provenance verified the contributor’s identity and checked the work against the Library’s published criteria. It does not endorse the work or its views.

## How contributors are verified

The Institute verifies every contributor in one of these ways. The work’s record shows which way and when. The evidence itself is kept privately by the Institute.

Organization email

The submission came from an address at the contributor’s organization’s own domain, passed that domain’s sender authentication (DKIM/SPF and DMARC), and the organization and the contributor’s place in it were checked.

Publication record

The contributor showed a public record that names them as the author: a prior publication, an ORCID record with verified works, or a faculty or employer profile. They then proved they control a contact address listed on that record.

Identity document

The contributor completed an identity check with a government-issued document and a live photo, through an identity verification service or a video call with Institute staff. The Institute keeps only the result, not the document.

Known to the Institute

The contributor is a member of the Library’s review panel and personally known to the Institute. A member never reviews their own work.

For every method, the contributor must be one of the work’s authors or be authorized by them, and approves the final record by replying from the address they submitted from.

## What the review panel checks

The Library’s review panel accepts a work when it meets all of these criteria. A decline always names the criterion the work did not meet. A panel member never reviews a work they wrote or submitted.

1.  A verified contributor. The contributor’s identity is verified, and they are an author of the work or authorized by its authors.
2.  On topic. The work addresses the Library’s subjects (trust, truth, knowledge, provenance and the human condition) within its listed disciplines and topics.
3.  No defamation or harassment. The work does not make false statements of fact about identifiable people or organizations, and does not target or harass them. Criticism of ideas, arguments and public conduct is welcome.
4.  Civil language. No profanity, slurs, obscenity or gratuitously abusive language.
5.  Clear rights. There is a clear basis for publishing the full text, and material owned by others is cleared.
6.  Lawful. The work does not incite violence or break the law.

The panel does not judge whether the argument is right, whether it agrees with it, or which side of a question it takes. The Library publishes opposing views on the same question, and viewpoint is never a reason to decline a work.

## What is public and what stays private

### Published with the work, and signed

-   The full text, title and summary
-   Authors’ names and affiliations
-   The contributor’s name
-   The submission reference and the date it was received
-   How and when the contributor was verified
-   The attestation version and the date the contributor approved the record
-   The date the review panel accepted the work

### Kept privately by the Institute

-   Email addresses and other contact details
-   The evidence used to verify identity (identity documents are held by the verification service, not the Institute)
-   Permission records
-   Individual reviewers’ votes and notes

## What the signature means

The Library of Provenance signs each work and its record under the [XION standard](/standards), with a certificate issued by the Institute of Provenance. Your browser checks the signature itself. A valid signature proves that the text and its record are exactly what the Library published, and who the record says submitted it. It does not mean the work is true, or that the Institute agrees with it.

## Corrections, disputes and withdrawal

If you believe a work misattributes authorship, infringes your rights or makes false statements about you, tell the Institute through the [contact page](/contact), naming the work. We review every report against the criteria above and may withdraw a work. A corrected work is published as a new signed version; the earlier signature never silently changes.
